Labrador puppies are in a league of their own. They’re smart, high-energy, and they chew everything — your shoes, your furniture, your TV remote. Labs were bred to retrieve, which means their instinct is to have something in their mouth at all times.
The good news: give a Lab puppy the right toy, and that energy goes somewhere productive. The wrong toy? It falls apart in twenty minutes, becomes a choking hazard, or just gets ignored.
We tested the top-rated options on Amazon to find the best toys for Labrador puppies in 2026 — built for their chewing power, sized for their growing mouths, and priced so you’re not replacing them every week.
Our Top Pick at a Glance
Best Overall: KONG Puppy — natural rubber, freezable, 4.6 stars with 52,000+ reviews. It’s the one toy every Lab puppy owner should start with.
Comparison Table
| Product | Type | Price | Stars | Reviews | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| KONG Puppy | Rubber chew / stuffable | $10.96 | 4.6 ⭐ | 52.5K | All Lab puppies |
| Benebone Puppy 2-Pack | Nylon chew | $14.20 | 4.5 ⭐ | 14K | Aggressive chewers |
| Nylabone Puppy Pacifier | Nylon chew | $9.99 | 4.5 ⭐ | 37K | Teething relief |
| Benebone Wishbone | Nylon chew | $10.98 | 4.5 ⭐ | 42.2K | Solo chewing |
| Nylabone Ring Bone | Nylon chew | $3.99 | 4.2 ⭐ | 40.5K | Budget pick |
The Best Toys for Labrador Puppies — Full Reviews
1. KONG Puppy — Best Overall
The KONG Puppy is the starting point for every Lab owner. It’s made from a natural rubber formula specifically designed for puppy teeth — softer than the adult KONG, so it’s gentle on developing gums while still standing up to serious chewing.
What makes it the best toy for Labrador puppies is the hollow center. Stuff it with peanut butter, kibble, or cream cheese and freeze it overnight. Your Lab puppy goes from bored and destructive to completely occupied for 20–30 minutes. Repeat daily.
With 52,500+ reviews and a 4.6-star rating, this is the most proven puppy toy on Amazon.
Pros:
- Vet recommended, natural rubber
- Stuffable and freezable — extends engagement
- Sized for puppies up to 35 lbs (medium)
- Bounces unpredictably — keeps Labs mentally stimulated
Cons:
- Not indestructible — aggressive adult-sized Labs will eventually chew through it
- Needs cleaning after each use
Bottom line: Buy this first. It’s the one toy Labs use every day.
2. Benebone Puppy 2-Pack (Maplestick + Zaggler) — Best for Aggressive Chewers
Labs chew hard. The Benebone Puppy 2-Pack gives you two different shapes — the Maplestick for straight gnawing and the Zaggler (a curved wishbone shape) for paws-down chewing — both made from real bacon-flavored nylon.
The real bacon isn’t just a gimmick. It’s worked into the nylon itself, so the scent doesn’t wear off after a few sessions. Lab puppies stay interested in these long after they’ve ignored every other toy in the house.
Made in the USA. 4.5 stars with 14,000+ reviews and 3K+ bought last month.
Pros:
- Two toys, one price — variety keeps Labs engaged
- Real bacon flavor baked into the nylon
- Curved ergonomic shape — easy for puppies to hold with paws
- Made in the USA
Cons:
- Not for puppies under 3 months
- Supervise use — discard when worn down to small pieces
Bottom line: Best value pack for Lab puppies who chew through everything.
3. Nylabone Puppy Pacifier — Best for Teething Relief
When your Lab puppy is teething hard — around 3 to 6 months — their gums hurt and they chew to relieve the pressure. The Nylabone Puppy Pacifier is designed exactly for this phase. The textured nubs massage sore gums while the bacon flavor keeps them coming back.
It’s sized for small puppies up to 25 lbs, which makes it ideal for young Labs before they hit their full chewing power. 4.5 stars with 37,000+ reviews and 5K+ bought last month.
Pros:
- Textured surface soothes teething gums
- Bacon-flavored nylon
- Affordable — under $10
- Durable for the teething stage
Cons:
- Size limit — puppies over 25 lbs will outgrow it fast
- Not a long-term toy — for the teething phase only
Bottom line: The go-to teething toy for Lab puppies 3–6 months old.
4. Benebone Wishbone — Best for Solo Chewing
The Benebone Wishbone is one of the best-designed chew toys on the market. The curved wishbone shape means your Lab puppy can pin it down with their paws and chew at the right angle — something most straight chew toys don’t allow.
Available in multiple sizes. For Lab puppies, start with Small. The real bacon or maple flavor is embedded throughout the nylon, not just on the surface. 4.5 stars with 42,200+ reviews and 30K+ bought last month — one of the top-selling dog toys on Amazon.
Pros:
- Ergonomic shape — Labs can chew without frustration
- Real flavor throughout, not just surface-level
- Multiple size options as your Lab grows
- Extremely popular — 30K+ sold last month
Cons:
- Not stuffable
- Must size up as your Lab grows
Bottom line: The best chew toy for Labs who like to go at it solo.
5. Nylabone Ring Bone — Best Budget Pick
Under $4. That’s the Nylabone Ring Bone. It’s a chicken-flavored nylon ring that handles real chewing and keeps Lab puppies busy without costing you anything. At this price, you can buy several and rotate them — Labs respond better to variety.
4.2 stars with 40,500+ reviews. Solid performer for the price.
Pros:
- Under $4 — lowest price on this list
- Durable nylon construction
- Chicken flavor
- 40,500+ reviews — proven track record
Cons:
- Less durable than Benebone for heavy chewers
- Basic design — no ergonomic features
Bottom line: Buy a few as backup toys or for rotation. Hard to beat at this price.
Buying Guide: What to Look for in Toys for Labrador Puppies
Match the toy to the chew level
Labs are moderate-to-aggressive chewers even as puppies. Avoid soft plush toys as a primary chew — they’ll destroy them in minutes, and the stuffing is a choking hazard. Stick with rubber or nylon as the base, with plush toys reserved for supervised play.
Size matters
A toy too small is a choking hazard. A toy too large is frustrating and ignored. For Lab puppies under 25 lbs, go Small. For 25–50 lbs, go Medium. Labs grow fast — plan to size up at around 6 months.
Puppy-specific formula
Adult chew toys are too hard for puppy teeth. KONG makes a specific Puppy formula (softer rubber). Benebone and Nylabone both have puppy lines. Never give a Lab puppy an adult-rated chew toy — it can crack developing teeth.
Mental stimulation matters as much as chewing
Labs are working dogs. They need their brain engaged, not just their mouth. Stuffable toys like the KONG Puppy serve double duty — chewing plus problem-solving. Add that to your rotation.
Frequently Asked Questions
What toys are best for Labrador puppies?
The KONG Puppy and Benebone Puppy 2-Pack are the two best starting points. KONG for stuffable engagement, Benebone for durable solo chewing. Between those two, you cover the main needs of a Lab puppy.
How long should a Labrador puppy chew per day?
There’s no strict limit, but 20–30 minutes of active chewing per session is typical. Rotate toys to keep interest high and inspect toys regularly for wear.
Are Nylabones safe for Labrador puppies?
Yes — Nylabone makes puppy-specific toys with softer nylon designed for developing teeth. Always choose the puppy line, not adult-rated Nylabones, and supervise use.
When should I replace my Lab puppy’s chew toy?
Replace any chew toy when pieces start breaking off large enough to swallow, or when the toy is worn down to a small nub. Labs go through toys — budget for replacements.
Can Lab puppies use KONG toys?
Yes — use the KONG Puppy specifically (pink or blue). It’s made from softer rubber than the Classic KONG and is designed for puppy teeth. Stuff with peanut butter and freeze for the best results.
Final Verdict
For most Lab puppy owners, start with two toys: the KONG Puppy for stuffed enrichment and the Benebone Puppy 2-Pack for durable chewing. Between those two, you have mental stimulation, teething relief, and something that actually lasts.
If you’re on a tight budget, grab the Nylabone Ring Bone for under $4 and rotate it with whatever else you have. Labs are easy to please — they just need something in their mouth.
Pick one, order today, and give your Lab puppy something better to chew than your furniture. If your Lab is a heavy chewer, see our guide to the best heavy-duty dog toys for chewers.
Disclosure: Barketto is reader-supported. When you buy through links on this site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. We only recommend products we’d use ourselves.